The First Recorded UFO Sighting in America
Uncover the fascinating story of America's first recorded UFO sightings by Puritans in 1639 and 1644, as documented by John Winthrop.

Exploring the Mysterious Lights of 1639
On that fateful night of March 1, 1639, Puritans living in the Massachusetts Bay Colony witnessed an event that would intrigue generations to come. As John Winthrop documented, James Everell and his companions encountered a mysterious light while rowing on the Muddy River, a sighting that would stand as one of America's earliest UFO cases.
Winthrop's account of the light's behavior was captivating. It flickered and dashed across the night sky, moving with incredible swiftness and fluctuating in shape. The transformation into a swine-like form astounded the boatmen, suggesting this otherworldly phenomenon was not just a natural occurrence but something far more curious.
When the astonishing spectacle faded, the men found themselves unexpectedly one mile upstream, an experience that left them bewildered. While some explanations have suggested they merely drifted unknowingly, the idea of a supernatural influence was ever-present within the Puritan mindset, as they sought to make sense of the inexplicable.
Five years later, Winthrop observed other celestial phenomena that stirred the community. Records of unexplained voices and glowing apparitions haunted Boston's skies, reinforcing the cultural legacy of a New World filled with mystery and the supernatural—elements that still captivate the imagination of modern Americans.
John Winthrop's Diary Accounts of UFOs
On March 1, 1639, John Winthrop, the governor of the Massachusetts Bay Colony, detailed in his diary a perplexing encounter with an unexplained light in the night sky. Describing the experience, he recounted how James Everell and two others observed a huge glowing object above the Muddy River that transformed in shape and darted quickly between them.
As Winthrop noted, when the light vanished, the boatmen found themselves mysteriously one mile upstream, with no recollection of their struggle against the tide. Some modern interpretations liken this unusual occurrence to theories of alien abduction, sparking curiosity about the nature of their experience—a phenomenon beyond the understanding of their era.
Five years later, on January 18, 1644, another peculiar sighting described by Winthrop involved two lights rising from the water near Boston. These luminescent figures danced through the sky, puzzling the observers with their eerie behaviors. Winthrop's accounts suggest that the colonies were not immune to the enigma of the skies—further establishing Massachusetts as a hub for early American UFO sightings.
In another entry, Winthrop provides context for a later incident involving a ghostly voice heard calling from the waters. This supernatural event followed an explosion aboard a vessel, leading to speculation that the voice belonged to a sailor thought to have perished due to his malevolent dealings. Winthrop’s writings weave together the themes of mystery, celestial phenomena, and the influence of the supernatural in the early American psyche.
Connecting Ancient Sightings to Modern UFO Phenomena
The fascination with UFOs isn't exclusively a product of the late 20th century. Throughout history, unusual lights and objects have captured human attention, with ancient civilizations frequently documenting their mysterious encounters in ways that resonate with today's UFO enthusiasts.
Ancient texts, from biblical scriptures to folklore, describe peculiar lights and phenomena in the sky. Cultures across the globe, such as the Greeks and Egyptians, reported fiery chariots and glowing spheres, suggesting a timeless intrigue with the unknown—a curiosity reflected in contemporary UFO experiences.
In modern contexts, sightings are often linked to extraterrestrial life. However, historical accounts frequently interpreted these phenomena through religious or mythological lenses. The way humanity has attempted to explain unexplainable events remains constant, whether viewed through the prism of ancient superstition or today's scientific skepticism.
The continuing dialogue between historical sightings and modern UFO reports illustrates humanity's enduring quest for understanding. Just as Puritans like John Winthrop documented their experiences, today's eyewitnesses contribute to an evolving narrative that shapes our views of the universe, blending the past with present-day wonders.